NEW York Color NYC Automatic Eyeliner Pencil Eye Liner Eyeliner 831 Basic Black | eBay
NYC HD Automatic Eyeliner Waterproof Pencil 005 DEEP PURPLE~COMBINED SHIPPING~ | eBay
Dupe for NYC Liquid Eyeliner (dip bottle with medium-point brush)? No longer made, but I want to surprise my BFF with dupe possibilities! : r/drugstoreMUA